Corporate Valuation, Oil & Gas

June 12, 2020

Themes from Q1 2020 Earnings Calls

Part 2: Mineral Aggregators

As discussed in our quarterly overview, the oil & gas industry took arguably its worst beating in history due to Saudi Arabia-Russia price war and demand destruction caused by COVID-19.  Rather than restating the events and underlying economics behind the drastic downturn in the market, it would be more beneficial to read Part One of this series and cut to the chase with Part Two of the Q1 2020 earnings calls, which focuses on mineral aggregators.

Theme 1: Dividend Policies Varying Moving Forward

Participants and investors seemed to question aggregators’ current and future distribution plans, as this asset class is primarily a yield investment vehicle.

  • “The $0.025 dividend payment reflects a payout ratio of 23% of pro forma free cash flow.  It really is simply about getting back to a more stable economic and energy environment.  I would expect that we’ll see our payout ratio return to its traditional level of 90% plus.” – Daniel Herz, President & CEO, Falcon Minerals
  • “We committed to a 100% payout ratio through the first quarter, and we want investors to know that our word is important, and we remain committed to following through and doing what we said we were going to do.” – Robert Roosa, CEO & Director, Brigham Minerals
  • “That resulted in us cutting the distribution to 25% of available cash.  And I think it’s going to be a very fluid process.  I can only really use the baseline of 25% for now.” – Travis Stice, CEO, Viper Energy Partners

Theme 2: Hedging: Defensive Strategies Leading to Limited Upside Exposure

Although mineral aggregators enjoy certain advantages relative to operators, their performance remains tied to commodity prices.  As a result of the uncertain and volatile pricing environment, there have been difficult decisions made in regard to hedging.  Some aggregators are hedged through 2021, limiting the potential upside of these investments if prices continue to increase.

  • “We currently have a substantial portion of our oil and natural gas production hedged in the form of swaps going out two years with prices for oil averaging in the low $40s and natural gas averaging around $2.49 per MMBTU.” – Robert Ravnaas, CEO & Chairman, Kimbell Royalty Partners
  • “Because of this market uncertainty and our concern that it may persist for some time, we have put in place substantial hedges for 2021 for both oil and has to further our already robust 2020 hedge positions.” – Jeff Wood, President & CFO, Black Stone Minerals

Theme 3: Aggregator Advantages Muted for the Moment

Unlike traditional royalty trusts, mineral aggregators reap the benefit of reinvesting capital to acquire new acreage.  This advantage, however, has been paused as the M&A market is in a standstill due to the wide bid-ask spread between buyers and sellers.  It will be interesting to monitor the performance of the aggregators closely if they are unable to benefit from their acquisition strategies.

  • “Right now, our acquisition machine is silent for the foreseeable future.  Now, mineral owners tend to be stickier with respect to perception of value, and there’s often less leverage in the mineral space.  So, I think it’s going to be pretty quiet here for the next couple quarters.” – Travis Stice, CEO, Viper Energy Partners
  • “The A&D market, as you might imagine, is pretty slow currently, but we expect it to pick up in the next, let’s call it, 2 to 6 months.  From an M&A perspective, we plan to continue to fund our micro acquisition strategy at current depressed commodity prices and continue to be well positioned as a consolidator in the highly fragmented minerals industry.” – Robert Ravnaas, CEO & Chairman, Kimbell Royalty Partners
  • “There will be production over time and likely growth over time.  And so sellers’ expectations will remain, I think, relatively high and they’ll be patient. – Daniel Herz, President & CEO, Falcon Minerals
 

Continue Reading

EP Second Quarter 2026 Permian Basin
E&P Second Quarter 2026

Region Focus: Permian Basin

The Permian Basin continued to demonstrate its resilience in the twelve-month period through June 30, 2026 (the review period). Despite a modest decline in rig counts, production reached new highs as operators continued to emphasize capital discipline, drilling efficiencies, and productivity improvements. Heightened geopolitical tensions introduced considerably greater volatility into commodity markets during the latter portion of the review period, yet oil prices ended above year-earlier levels and Permian public companies posted strong stock price appreciation. While basin operators continue to balance disciplined capital allocation with long-term production growth, the Permian remains the nation’s premier oil-producing basin and continues to demonstrate its ability to adapt to changing market conditions.
Just Released: Q2 2026 Oil & Gas Industry Newsletter
Just Released: Q2 2026 Oil & Gas Industry Newsletter
Regional Focus: The Permian BasinThe Permian continued to demonstrate its resilience in the twelve-month period through June 30, 2026 (the review period). Despite a modest decline in rig counts, production reached new highs as operators continued to emphasize capital discipline, drilling efficiencies, and productivity improvements. Heightened geopolitical tensions introduced considerably greater volatility into commodity markets during the latter portion of the review period, yet oil prices ended above year-earlier levels and Permian public companies posted strong stock price appreciation. While basin operators continue to balance disciplined capital allocation with long-term production growth, the Permian remains the nation’s premier oil-producing basin and continues to demonstrate its ability to adapt to changing market conditions.
Bryce Erickson Discusses the Changing Economics of Upstream Asset Valuations with Hart Energy
Bryce Erickson Discusses the Changing Economics of Upstream Asset Valuations with Hart Energy
Mercer Capital’s Energy Industry Team Leader, Bryce Erickson, ASA, MRICS, recently shared his perspective on upstream asset valuations in two features published by Hart Energy.Bryce joined other industry professionals at Hart Energy’s 2026 Energy Capital Conference, where he participated in the panel, “Asset Valuations in a High-Price World: Separating Signal from Noise.” The discussion examined how investors, lenders, and operators are assessing energy assets amid elevated commodity prices, increasingly scarce drilling inventory, and continued consolidation across the upstream sector.Markets Turn Their Attention to Tier 2 and Tier 3 AcreageIn a video interview with Hart Energy’s Chris Mathews, Bryce discusses how the scarcity of available Tier 1 acreage is directing greater attention toward Tier 2 and Tier 3 opportunities.As the inventory of premium drilling locations becomes increasingly concentrated, buyers are looking more closely at assets that may previously have received less attention. Higher commodity prices and continued improvements in drilling and completion techniques can make some of these locations more economically attractive. However, broad acreage classifications tell only part of the story. Investors must still examine the specific geology, operating costs, development plans, decline expectations, and risks associated with each asset. Bryce’s comments underscore the importance of disciplined, asset-specific underwriting as competition expands beyond traditionally defined core acreage.How the “Last Cheap Barrels” May Influence BidsHart Energy’s Lisa El-Amin further explores the relationship between inventory scarcity and upstream deal values in “How the Last Cheap Barrels May Be Shaping Today’s Bids” (subscription required).The article considers how competition is shifting toward a diminishing pool of drilling locations capable of generating attractive returns at approximately $50 oil, with much of that inventory concentrated in the Permian Basin. As low-breakeven locations become harder to acquire or replace, buyers may be willing to place greater value on assets offering durable inventory, favorable cost structures, and a long development runway. The result is an M&A market in which bids are increasingly influenced by the quality and scarcity of future drilling opportunities—not simply current production or near-term commodity prices.Valuation ImplicationsTogether, the two Hart Energy features highlight that asset quality and inventory durability are becoming more visible, and potentially more valuable, as the shale sector matures.Determining how these factors affect a particular company or asset requires careful analysis of its reserves, development inventory, cost structure, operating assumptions, and expected cash flows. Mercer Capital has assisted clients with a wide range of valuation needs in the upstream oil and gas industry across both conventional and unconventional plays in North America and around the world. Contact a Mercer Capital professional to discuss your valuation needs in confidence.

Cart

Your cart is empty