Koons v. Commissioner
It appears that Mr. Koons’ careful estate planning, involving a significant sale and redemption transaction of business operations to provide liquidity and flexibility in his later years, was disrupted by an untimely death. While estate planning professionals can hardly advise against a premature passing, the disruption here highlights the importance of starting early with business valuation input to help avoid a complex confluence of strategic transactions within a narrow time frame.
Key Issues
The Court rejected the Estate’s claim seeking a 31.7% marketability discount applied to a Revocable Trust’s ownership interest in a familyowned Limited Liability Company. The Estate’s expert calculated a marketability discount through a regression analysis. It was his opinion that a substantial risk existed that the Trust’s contemplated redemptions of Member Interests, contracted for as part of a planned redemption, might not be consummated. The contemplated redemptions would place the Trust in a voting control position.
The Court agreed with the IRS expert’s conclusion that the referenced redemption offers were binding contracts and were expected to be consummated. The lower risk implicit in the likelihood of a transaction, in context with the implicit voting control position, resulted in the IRS marketability discount of 7.5%, which was accepted by the Court.
The Court also held that claimed interest expense in the amount of $71,419,497 on a $10,750,000 loan from CI LLC to the John F. Koons III Revocable Trust is not deductible to the Estate as an essential expense. The Trust had borrowed the $10.75 million from the LLC in order to pay estate taxes.
Background
John Koons III (the “decedent” or “Koons”) died on March 3, 2005. At issue before the court was the value of his interest in his Revocable Trust (the “Trust’), as well as the deductibility of claimed interest expense on a loan which was incurred by the Trust to make payments on the estate tax liability.
In 1934, the father of John Koons III began buying shares in the Burger Brewing Co., which owned and operated a Cincinnati brewery. The decedent also purchased shares and later became the company’s president and CEO. Under Koons’ leadership, the company began bottling and distributing Pepsi soft drink products in the 1960s. In the 1970s the company stopped brewing beer altogether, and changed its name to Central Investment Corp. (“CIC”). Diversifying its business further, it expanded into the business of selling food and drinks from vending machines.
In 1997, CIC was in a dispute with PepsiCo about whether CIC had the exclusive right to sell Pepsi fountain syrup directly to restaurants, movie theatres, and other customers in its territory. Litigation ensued, and PepsiCo eventually suggested that the lawsuit could be settled if CIC exited the Pepsi system. CIC negotiated with PepsiAmericas, Inc., (“PAS”), the nation’s second largest Pepsi-Cola bottling company. Negotiations were expanded to include the sale of CIC’s vending-machine business.
In preparation for the sale of its soft drink and vending machine business, Central Investment LLC (“CI LLC”) was set up in August 2004 as a wholly owned subsidiary of CIC, to receive all the nonsoft-drink and non-vending-machine assets. Koons and his children owned the same percentage in the newly-formed CI LLC as they did in CIC. However, the children were required to approve the sale transaction. Further, their interests in CI LLC were subject to redemption agreements within 90 days of the PAS transaction.
The PAS sale transaction was effected on January 12, 2005.