Financial Reporting Valuation, Investment Management

July 20, 2015

Portfolio Valuation: How to Value Venture Capital Portfolio Investments

The following outlines our process when providing periodic fair value marks for venture capital fund investments in pre-public companies.

Venture-Capital-Valuation-Process

Examine the most recent financing round economics

The transaction underlying the initiation of an investment position can provide three critical pieces of information from a valuation perspective:

  • Size of the aggregate investment and per share price.
  • Rights and protections accorded to the newest round of securities.
  • Usually, but not always, an indication of the underlying enterprise value from the investor’s perspective.
Deal terms commonly reported in the press (example) focus on the size of the aggregate investment and per share price. The term "valuation" is usually a headline-shorthand for implied post-money value that assumes all equity securities in the company’s capital structure have identical rights and protections. While elegant, this approach glosses over the fact that for pre-public companies, securities with differing rights and protections should and do command different prices. The option pricing method (OPM) is an alternative that explicitly models the rights of each equity class and makes generalized assumptions about the future trajectory of the company to deduce values for the various securities. Valuation specialists can also use the probability-weighted expected return method (PWERM) to evaluate potential proceeds from, and the likelihood of, several exit scenarios for a company. Total proceeds from each scenario would then be allocated to the various classes of equity based on their relative rights. The use of PWERM is particularly viable if there is sufficient visibility into the future exit prospects for the company. The economics of the most recent financing round helps calibrate inputs used in both the OPM and PWERM.
  • Under the OPM, a backsolve procedure provides indications of total equity and enterprise value based on the pricing and terms the most recent financing round. The indicated enterprise value and a set of future cash flow projections, taken together, imply a rate of return (discount rate) that may be reasonable for the company. Multiples implied by the indicated enterprise value, juxtaposed with information from publicly traded companies or related transactions, can yield valuation-useful inferences.
  • Under the PWERM, in addition to informing discount rates and providing comparisons with market multiples, the most recent financing round can inform the relative likelihood of the various exit scenarios.
When available, indications of enterprise value from the investor’s perspectives can further inform the inputs used in the various valuation methods. In addition to the quantitative inputs enumerated above, discussions and documentation around the recent financing round can provide critical qualitative information, as well.

Adjust valuation inputs to measurement date

Between a funding round and subsequent measurement dates, the performance of the company and changes in market conditions can provide context for any adjustments that may be warranted for the valuation inputs. Deterioration in actual financial projections may warrant revisiting the set of projected cash flows, while improvements in market multiples for similar companies may suggest better pricing may be available for the company at exit. Interest from potential acquirers (or withdrawal of prior interest) and general IPO trends can inform inputs related to the relative likelihood of the various exit scenarios.

Measure fair value

Measuring fair value of the subject security entails using the OPM and PWERM, as appropriate and viable, in conjunction with valuation inputs that are relevant at the measurement date. ASC 820 defines fair value as, "The price that would be received to sell an asset or paid to transfer a liability in an orderly transaction between market participants at the measurement date."

Reconciliation and tests of reasonableness

A sanity check to scrutinize fair value outputs is an important element of the measurement process. Specifically as it relates to venture capital investments in pre-public companies, such a check would reconcile a fair value indication at the current measurement date with a mark from the prior period in light of both changes in the subject company, and changes in market conditions.

Mercer Capital assists a range of alternative investment funds, including venture capital firms, in periodically measuring the fair value of portfolio assets for financial reporting purposes to the satisfaction of the general partners and fund auditors. Call us – we would like to work with you to define appropriate fund valuation policies and procedures, and provide independent opinions of value.

Author
Sujan Rajbhandary
Senior Vice President
Learn More

Continue Reading

When RIA Owners Disagree on Value
When RIA Owners Disagree on Value

Choosing the Appraiser, the Process, and the Rules of Engagement

Valuation disputes among RIA owners require more than a defensible appraisal—they also require a clear process for selecting a qualified, independent appraiser and establishing fair rules of engagement. Thoughtful dispute-resolution provisions can help parties reach a credible conclusion even when perspectives on value differ.
RIA Valuation Insights Blog Investment Management
Read Now
Mercer Capital to Sponsor and Speak at Bank Director’s 2026 Bank Board Forum
Mercer Capital to Sponsor and Speak at Bank Director’s 2026 Bank Board Forum
Mercer Capital is pleased to sponsor Bank Director’s 2026 Bank Board Forum, taking place September 20 to 23, 2026, at the JW Marriott Austin in Austin, Texas. Jeff Davis and Andy Gibbs will attend and speak on behalf of the firm.The Bank Board Forum brings together bank directors and senior executives from across the country to examine the issues affecting bank leadership, governance, strategy, risk, technology, talent, and growth. This year’s program features main-stage presentations and specialized tracks designed for leaders focused on Audit & Risk, Compensation & Talent, and Governance & Strategy.Davis and Gibbs will present the breakout session “Community Bank 2027 Budget Preview: Opportunities and Challenges.” As boards review proposed budgets for the coming year, the session will examine the industry, strategic, and performance trends shaping the outlook for community banks. Topics will include the financial trends that may continue into 2027, the factors behind the recovery in bank stocks during 2026, the sustainability of that momentum, capital management amid easing capital requirements, and other evolving industry conditions.Jeff Davis, CFA, is Managing Director of Mercer Capital’s Financial Institutions Group. He provides valuation and transaction advisory services to banks and other financial institutions and has extensive experience analyzing publicly traded banks and specialty finance companies. Before rejoining Mercer Capital, Jeff spent 13 years as a sell-side analyst and held senior positions with Guggenheim Securities and FTN Equity Capital Markets. He is a frequent speaker at banking industry conferences and regularly presents to boards of directors and executive management teams.Andy Gibbs, CFA, CPA/ABV, is a Senior Vice President and leads Mercer Capital’s Depository Institutions Group. He provides valuation and corporate advisory services to financial institutions for mergers and acquisitions, employee stock ownership plans, corporate planning and reorganizations, financial reporting, and tax-related matters. Andy is a frequent speaker on community bank valuation and is a co-author of The Bank Director’s Valuation Handbook: What Every Director Must Know About Valuation and other books focused on financial institutions.Mercer Capital looks forward to connecting with bank leaders in Austin and contributing its valuation and transaction advisory perspective to the discussion about the opportunities and challenges facing community banks in 2027. Additional information is available on the Bank Board Forum conference website: https://www.bankdirector.com/event/bank-board-forum-2026/
Banks
Read Now
Mercer Capital to Sponsor the Association of Trust Organizations 2026 Annual Meeting
Mercer Capital to Sponsor the Association of Trust Organizations 2026 Annual Meeting
Mercer Capital is pleased to sponsor the Association of Trust Organizations’ 2026 Annual Meeting, taking place September 21-23, 2026, at the Grand Hyatt Deer Valley in Park City, Utah. Matt Crow, Brooks Hamner, and Zach Milam will attend on behalf of the firm.The 2026 Annual Meeting is a 1.5-day conference designed exclusively for the trust industry and will feature more than 13 hours of roundtables, panels, and networking. One of the featured sessions is Tuesday afternoon’s Session VI, “What Makes a Trust Company Worth More? Building Value Before the Deal,” which will be moderated by Matt Crow. The panel will explore the factors that drive valuation, how buyers and sellers evaluate opportunities, and what firms can do today to maximize enterprise value.Matt Crow, CFA, ASA, is the CEO of Mercer Capital and leads the firm’s Investment Management Industry team. He works with RIAs, independent trust companies, broker-dealers, and investment consulting firms on valuation matters related to corporate planning and reorganization, transactions, employee stock ownership plans, tax issues, and intangible asset valuations. Matt is also a frequent contributor to Mercer Capital’s RIA Valuation Insights blog.Brooks Hamner, CFA, ASA, is a Senior Vice President and a senior member of Mercer Capital’s Investment Management Industry team. He provides valuation services to RIAs, independent trust companies, asset managers, wealth management firms, broker-dealers, and investment consultants, and he also advises clients buying or selling their business.Zach Milam, CFA, is a Vice President and a senior member of Mercer Capital’s Investment Management Industry team. He has experience in corporate planning and reorganizations, financial reporting, fairness opinions, litigation support, employee stock ownership plans, and estate and gift tax planning and compliance matters.Mercer Capital regularly works with RIAs, independent trust companies, broker-dealers, and other investment management clients on valuation and advisory matters, and the firm looks forward to connecting with attendees in Park City. Visit the conference website to learn more about this year’s Annual Meeting: https://trustorgs.com/annual-meeting/.
Investment Management
Read Now

Cart

Your cart is empty